We all went to bed once we got home on Sunday night, so we ended up doing their Easter baskets first thing Monday morning.
I ordered a basket for Logan that was the same style as Olivia's. The boy choices were limited, so I went with the best option. (Unfortunately, you can't choose the font.)
Logan got a stuffed bunny, a toy, a soft (boy!) book, a hat for summer, sunglasses, and his eggs had bottle labels in them.
Olivia got a Minnie Mouse toy, Frozen book, Doc McStuffins puzzle, Sofia the first amulet, a chocolate bunny, peeps, and some eggs filled with goodies. Out of all of the "non food" lists I saw out there, there was really nothing we needed. We have so many art supplies, bubbles, chalk, socks, bathroom supplies, etc. So her basket ended up being all fun.
She went right for the chocolate!
I think she was pleased.